By Eric Stites, Franchise Business Review

It’s 10:30 am. A key employee just called out sick.

A customer is upset and posted about it on Instagram. Labor costs are running 20 percent over target for the month. The new marketing program from corporate has arrived, and the team needs to be fully up to speed in three days. And last week’s numbers just posted — and the franchise owner is texting with questions.

For unit-level managers, it’s not one challenge. It’s one battle after another, every single day.

And here’s what many franchisors and franchisees miss: those daily battles aren’t just operational headaches. They are the moments that determine employee engagement, customer experience, and unit-level financial performance. How a manager shows up in those moments — how they lead, communicate, and support their team — is the single greatest driver of results inside any franchise business.

Where Franchise Performance Is Won or Lost

Franchising is built on systems — proven models, brand standards, and replicable processes designed to deliver consistency at scale. But systems don’t execute themselves. People do. And the person responsible for translating the brand promise into reality — every shift, every customer, every day — is the unit-level manager.

Gallup’s research finds that managers account for at least 70 percent of the variance in team engagement. At FBR, we see this play out in our data every day. The brands with the highest franchisee satisfaction and strongest unit economics aren’t always the ones with the best products or the biggest marketing budgets. They’re the ones with the best managers.

Yet despite their outsized impact, unit managers are often:

  • Undertrained in people management and communication
  • Measured on compliance metrics, not culture or customer experience
  • Promoted for tenure, not leadership ability
  • Left to navigate increasing complexity with limited support or development

The result? Wide performance variation across units within the same brand — despite identical systems, products, and playbooks. Same brand, same menu, same training manual. Completely different results. The differentiator is almost always the manager.

The Three Levers of Unit-Level Performance

At the unit level, performance isn’t driven by strategy decks or marketing campaigns. It’s driven by execution — and execution lives with the manager. Every day, unit managers pull three critical levers that determine whether a business thrives or struggles.

  1. Employee Engagement: Managers set the tone for the entire workplace. They hire, onboard, coach, recognize, and retain employees. Data shows the #1 reason employees leave isn’t pay — it’s their manager. In franchise environments, where hourly turnover can run 100–150 percent annually, manager quality isn’t a soft metric. It’s an economic one.
  2. Customer Experience: Customers don’t experience the brand — they experience the team in front of them. A motivated, well-coached team delivers great experiences. A burned-out, disengaged team delivers something else entirely. And that one bad experience gets posted online before the customer even reaches their car.
  3. Financial Performance: Managers directly impact labor efficiency, scheduling, waste, and productivity. A great manager runs a tight ship without burning people out. The best franchise owners will tell you: find a great manager, and the P&L follows.

The Real Problem: Underinvestment in Frontline Leadership

Despite their importance, unit-level managers are often the most underdeveloped role in a franchise system. We’ve spent years at FBR surveying franchise employees, and one pattern comes up over and over again: managers don’t feel equipped.

They feel undertrained for the people side of their job. They feel unsupported when things get hard. They feel like their feedback goes nowhere. And when managers feel that way, their teams feel it too. Disengagement is contagious, and it almost always spreads from the top of the unit down.

Here’s the uncomfortable truth: most franchise systems don’t have consistency problems. They have manager consistency problems. The operational playbook is often excellent. The gap is in leadership capability — and that gap is costing franchisors and franchisees far more than they realize. The good news: it’s a solvable problem. But it requires treating manager development as a strategic investment, not an afterthought.

Rethinking Manager Development in Franchising

The most forward-thinking franchise brands we work with are making four meaningful shifts in how they think about and invest in their unit managers:

  1. Move Beyond Operational Training: Leadership is a skill, and it must be taught and reinforced. Knowing how to run a shift doesn’t automatically translate into knowing how to lead people, deliver difficult feedback, or re-engage a disengaged team member. The brands that invest in ongoing leadership development — not just onboarding checklists — see measurably better outcomes in retention and unit performance.
  2. Implement Continuous Listening: Relying solely on annual surveys is not enough. By the time results are compiled, the employee who was quietly disengaged months ago has already left. The best franchise systems are moving toward continuous feedback loops: short, frequent pulse checks that give managers real-time visibility into team sentiment and give franchisors early warning before problems escalate. You can’t fix what you can’t see.
  3. Measure What Actually Drives Performance: If you’re only measuring ops scores and mystery shops, you’re only seeing part of the picture. Employee engagement and manager effectiveness are leading indicators — they predict financial performance before it shows up in the P&L. Expanding your measurement framework isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s a competitive advantage.
  4. Build a Manager Pipeline Great managers aren’t just found — they’re developed. The strongest systems we work with identify high-potential employees early, invest in their growth, and create visible career paths. Building a pipeline also reduces the cycle where someone gets moved into management because there’s no one else, not because they’re ready.

The Flywheel Effect of Great Management

When franchise systems get this right, the results compound. Better managers create more engaged employees. More engaged employees deliver stronger customer experiences. Stronger experiences drive revenue. And healthy revenue supports better unit economics, happier franchisees, and a stronger brand.

We see this in the FBR data every year. The brands at the top of our satisfaction rankings share a common thread: they’ve figured out that investing in their managers is the highest-return investment they can make.

A Final Thought

The most important person in any franchise system isn’t at headquarters. It’s the manager running the unit every day — navigating one battle after another, often with less support than they deserve.

The question for every franchisor and franchisee right now is a simple one: Are we giving managers the tools to win?

Because if we’re not investing in the people who carry the brand on their shoulders every day, we’re not really investing in the brand at all.

Eric Stites is the founder of Franchise Business Review, a market research firm focused on franchisee, employee, and customer experience. Eric and the FBR team work with franchise brands to better understand their people insights, the drivers of unit-level performance and engagement, and help brands drive better results. Eric would like to give special thanks to Paul Thomas Anderson and the Oscar-winning film One Battle After Another for lending the perfect theme for this piece. For more information about IFA supplier member Franchise Business Review, please visit franchise.org/suppliers/franchise-business-review/.

Search